Showing 13–24 of 40 results
$14.99
Select options
A creepy, crispy, and chewy chocolate chip cookie made with semi-sweet morsels
$39.99
A childhood favorite growing up - "mom's" sugar cookies. Unlike other sugar cookies, these are soft, chewy and decorated with royal icing.
Select options 
$9.99
This dark chocolate cookie makes for a spooky and frighteningly delicious Halloween treat
Select options 
$24.99 – $39.99
Select options
Medium Tray (48 cookies)
Includes Creepy Crawly Chocolate Chip, Bloody Eyeball Cheesecakes, Dark Chocolate Halloween Chip, Peanut Butter Spiders, One-eyed Monster Buckeyes, Thumbprints
Small Tray (30 cookies)
Includes Creepy Crawly Chocolate Chip, Bloody Eyeball Cheesecakes, Dark Chocolate Halloween Chip, Peanut Butter Spiders, One-eyed Monster Buckeyes, Thumbprints
$9.99 – $17.99
Peanut butter milk chocolate chip cookies in the shape of a heart with your favorite candy topping
Select options 
$14.99 – $29.99
Peanut butter milk chocolate chip cookie with blissful pieces of Hershey Bar
Select options 
$29.99
Add to cart
Kids Christmas Cookie Tray (18 cookies)
Includes: Sugar (cut outs), Chocolate Chip, Iced Thumbprints
$14.99
A light and flaky cookie with a sweet, creamy filling. It will be love at first bite!
Select options 
