Set your main menu in Appearance > Menus

Search
Search

Shop

Return to Previous Page

Showing 1–12 of 40 results
Quick View
,
Apricot Cream Cheese Thumbprints
$9.99
Rich cream cheese and buttery cookie filled with apricot preserves
Select options
Quick View
,
Bloody Eyeball Cheesecakes
$9.99
A "trick" or delicious "treat" of white chocolate cheesecakes with a graham cracker crust and strawberry topping
Select options
Quick View
, , ,
Buckeyes
$9.99
Creamy peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate
Select options
Quick View
, ,
Butter Balls
$9.99
Butterball cookies, sugared and nut-filled
Select options
Quick View
,
Caramel Cups
$9.99
A flaky crust with a creamy caramel filling, topped with a light frosting
Select options
Quick View
Chocolate Chip
$11.99 – $19.99
Crisp and chewy chocolate chip cookie made with semi-sweet morsels
Select options
Quick View
,
Chocolate Covered Oreos
$14.99
Oreo cookies covered in chocolate
Select options
Quick View
Christmas Cookie Tray
$64.99
Variety Cookie Tray (72 cookies) - Serves 12-24 people.
Includes Thumbprints, Butter Balls, Magic Cookie Bars, Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodles, Buckeyes, Peanut Butter Blossoms
*Please note photo is that of a custom tray which are available upon request for additional charge
Add to cart
Quick View
, ,
Conversation Sugar Cookies
$11.99 – $23.99
Express your love with these soft and chewy sugar cookies iced with pastel colored royal icing
Select options
Quick View
Cookie Bouquets – All Occasions
$14.99
A tasty bouquet of three cookies of your choice.  Decorated with a greeting of your choice and "grown" in a decorated flower pot.
Select options
Quick View
Cookie Cakes
$19.99
Great for all occasions, enjoy a mouthwatering cookie cake (12")
Select options
Quick View
Cookie Cakes (Candy topped)
$24.99
Great for all occasions, enjoy a mouthwatering Cookie Cake drizzled with milk chocolate and your favorite candy toppings.
Select options
close